Fleets target driver pay raises in select markets

Carriers adjust compensation as competition for qualified truck drivers starts to rise

Truck driver in cab Several factors are driving raises, including regulatory changes, an aging workforce, improving freight conditions and growing competition from skilled trades. (Ivan Pantic/Getty Images)

Key Takeaways:Toggle View of Key Takeaways

  • At least eight high-profile fleets have announced pay raises and new incentives since May 11, targeting select lanes, regions and hard-to-fill driving jobs.
  • Industry experts said qualified driver supply is tightening before freight demand fully recovers, despite mixed signals from rates, turnover and capacity demand.
  • Shaver expects targeted pay increases and creative hiring incentives to continue into 2027, particularly for specific jobs and geographic markets.

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

The trucking industry is facing pressure to increase driver pay in select lanes and regions, which may indicate the start of a larger shift.

Anderson Trucking Service, Crete Carrier, Fleetmaster Express, GP Transco, K&B Transportation, Nussbaum Transportation, Roehl Transport and USA Truck are among the fleets that have announced pay raises and new incentives since May 11.

“The data we have been collecting has been pointing to compensation and home time being the top two priorities for drivers,” said Priscilla Peters, vice president of marketing at Conversion Interactive Agency. “As the freight market improves and competition for drivers is intensifying, fleets are evaluating their driver pay packages and how they compete.”

Peters hasn’t seen across-the-board pay raises for truckers in recent years. But she has seen more targeted increases in specific lanes and markets where fleets need to stay competitive. She identified several factors driving these pay raises, including regulatory changes, an aging workforce, improving freight conditions and growing competition from skilled trades.



“The biggest headwind right now is finding qualified drivers,” Peters said. “If recruiting is already challenging with only modest freight improvements, imagine what happens when freight demand really picks up. Competition for drivers and pressure to raise pay will only intensify.”

Peters warned that this intensifying pressure could put even more strain on carriers already operating on thin margins. She stressed that carriers can’t afford to guess how their driving jobs compare with the competition and urged them to understand what other fleets are offering.

“Anybody that’s been following driver pay for multiple years knows driver pay has been changing, and how drivers want to get paid is changing,” said Lars Offerdahl, vice president of van operations at ATS. “That’s just like any industry as it evolves. Some of our changes on the van side were even to align more with that evolution.”

Offerdahl added that this has involved learning from drivers to better align the pay structure with their preferences. This has led the company to begin moving toward a cost-per-mile pay model, in addition to increasing pay, since that is what most drivers are familiar with. ATS ranks No. 31 on the Transport Topics Top 100 list of the largest for-hire carriers in North America.

“We’ve been tracking a steady stream of pay changes, and we’re seeing the early signs of a shift in the driver labor market,” said Leah Shaver, president of the National Transportation Institute. “We are also seeing that pay isn’t moving everywhere or for every job at the same time.”

Image
Driver in cab

(Tempura/Getty Images)

Shaver added that most of that activity is concentrated in over-the-road and specialized roles, established teams and markets where qualified drivers are becoming more difficult to attract. She suspects fleets are responding to real competitive pressure because some have issued multiple pay raises.

“While freight conditions aren’t currently supporting another 2021-style pay race, I think this is an early indication that the available pool of qualified drivers is tightening,” Shaver said.

Shaver noted that the four factors that typically drive movement in driver compensation are turnover, driver supply, freight rates and demand for capacity. But she currently views those indicators as sending mixed signals, which explains the more targeted increases. She highlighted freight rates, driver experience and retention as potential headwinds.

“The larger trend I’m watching is that driver supply is tightening before freight demand has fully recovered,” Shaver said. “That’s a very different dynamic than we’ve seen in some previous cycles, and it could have significant implications when freight volumes and rates begin moving.”

Shaver expects to see more targeted pay increases and creative hiring incentives into 2027. She noted that this will continue to focus on specific driving jobs and geographic markets.

RoadSigns

PCS Software CEO Mark Hill discusses the advance of AI in the trucking industry. Tune in above or by going to RoadSigns.ttnews.com.  

“After a long-stagnant market, I am happy to report a positive shift in the driver recruiting market,” said Darin Williams, president of online driver job application and advertising company CDLjobs.com. “For the first time in a long time, the jobs posted increased at a higher rate than the applications submitted, perhaps signaling that carriers will need more drivers soon.”

Williams also has seen heightened interest in targeted lead-generation services, with more clients advertising in specific locations instead of seeking national coverage.

“Carriers are starting to position themselves for a more competitive hiring environment, even if the freight market hasn’t fully recovered,” Tenstreet CEO Tim Crawford said. “Drivers have been staying in their jobs longer, but our data suggests that’s partly because they’ve been reluctant to move in an uncertain market.”

Crawford warned that carriers may have to work harder to recruit and retain drivers as conditions improve. He stressed that drivers have more reasons to evaluate employers as they seek consistent miles, predictable earnings, good communication and trust in their carrier.

“The obvious challenge is that carriers face cost pressure while freight conditions remain uncertain,” Crawford said. “If drivers deal with inconsistent miles, poor communication or frustrating onboarding and administrative processes, they’re likely to check out the competition.”

 

Newsletter Signup

Subscribe to Transport Topics

Subscribe  Gift a Subscription

FOLLOW US ON GOOGLE NEWS