Commodities just posted the longest losing streak in more than three years, and analysts and investors are giving conflicting signals over whether the worst is over.
The Bloomberg Commodity Index fell 2.5% in the third quarter amid a stronger dollar, trade frictions and concerns over the Chinese-demand outlook. Copper slid into bear markets and gold posted its longest run of monthly losses in two decades in September. Crude oil was among the few bright spots. On Oct. 1, the Bloomberg gauge advanced 0.1% at 8:47 a.m. in New York.
Analysts at banks including Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and JPMorgan Chase & Co. are forecasting a turnaround as growth in top economies stays strong and signs of tight supplies emerge in some markets. Investors aren’t yet sharing their enthusiasm.
“Overall, we’re still cautious on commodities,” said Rob Haworth, who helps oversee $156 billion at U.S. Bank Wealth Management in Seattle. “Emerging markets remain somewhat stressed. If you are looking for emerging markets and China for growth to rebound and get a better story out of industrial metals, I don’t think we are there yet.”
The Bloomberg Commodity Index, which tracks returns for 22 components, is down about 3.3% this year, helping curb enthusiasm for the asset class, especially as U.S. equities trade near all-time highs. The gauge’s three straight quarterly losses mark the longest slump since the first quarter of 2015.
Investors pulled $2.57 billion from long-only exchange-traded funds linked to broad baskets of raw materials in the third quarter, including about $140 million in September, data compiled by Bloomberg Intelligence through Sept. 28 show. Total assets across all commodity ETFs have slid by $23 billion since April.
Money managers also have been exiting. Hedge funds and other large speculators pared their combined net-long position across 18 commodities for six straight weeks through mid-September to the lowest since June 2017, U.S. government data show. While they added to bullish wagers in the latest week, the bets are still down by almost half this year.
The following outlines the performance and prospects for some of the biggest commodity movers in the third quarter.
Soybean growers in the United States are facing increased risk of a prolonged battle between the largest economies, according to agribusiness giant Bunge Ltd. China slapped tariffs on American beans in retaliation to Trump administration measures, and buyers in the Asian nation are turning to other sources of supply. Soy futures posted a second straight quarterly loss.
Gold had a sixth straight monthly decline in September, the longest string of losses since 1997. The metal is being buffeted by rising U.S. interest rates, the dollar holding near recent highs and stronger returns across other assets. The U.S.-China trade war hasn’t revived haven demand for bullion as a haven, and with investors showing “scant risk aversion,” it may need a bigger catalyst to rebound, said Jim Wyckoff at Kitco Metals Inc.
The outlook is better in crude oil, according to U.S. Bank Wealth Management’s Haworth and Greg Sharenow, co-manager at Pimco’s CommoditiesPLUS Strategy Fund.
With renewed sanctions on Iran set for November, OPEC has signaled it will only produce enough crude to meet demand and won’t send additional supplies onto the market. Meanwhile, in the United States, bottlenecks in the Permian Basin have kept U.S. weekly crude production flat. Prices posted a fifth quarterly advance in London — the longest rally since June 2008.
Any trade concerns that may have affected the oil market “have been second order to the impact of the re-imposition of sanctions on Iran, which has been much more meaningful,” Sharenow said in an interview.
U.S. natural gas futures climbed 2.9% in the third quarter, the biggest gain since 2012 for that period. Inventories are at the lowest for this time of year in more than a decade, and Bloomberg Intelligence sees futures testing $4 per million British thermal units, about a dollar above current prices.
Wheat also may be set for gains, after years of bumper global harvests, drought and heat waves curbed production in many countries this season and boosted prices. World stockpiles are tightening, and crop prospects in Australia — a significant exporter —have worsened, Rabobank said in a report. Russia’s “red hot” export pace also is unlikely to last, the bank said.
Copper futures in New York fell 5.4% in the third quarter and are down 15% this year. Recent gains in the metal may bode well for commodities. Copper, often considered a bellwether of global growth, gained 5% in September, helped by optimism that broader U.S. tariffs will prompt China to invest more heavily in areas such as infrastructure to shore up its domestic economy.
Some of that sentiment may be starting to seep into investor views. The Bloomberg Commodity Index was up 1.7% in September after three straight monthly declines. The gauge also has posted two straight weekly increases.
“While U.S.-China trade tensions are unlikely to fade, China’s growth-supportive policy response will likely spur a year-end rally in some of the weakest performing commodities sectors,” JPMorgan analysts including Abhishek Deshpande said in a Sept. 21 report.