ATA proposes 6 steps to help FMCSA combat ELD fraud

New report calls for independent certification, automated checks and stronger enforcement

| Updated:
Vehicles on mountain road Fleets cited for ELD tampering have a 56% higher crash rate, according to the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance. (Bilanol/Getty Images)

Key Takeaways:Toggle View of Key Takeaways

  • American Trucking Associations released six ELD fraud recommendations on Nov. 16, including U.S.-based vendor requirements and independent device certification.
  • The report followed FMCSA’s removal of 133 ELDs from its registry, while fleets cited for ELD tampering have a 56% higher crash rate.
  • ATA urged FMCSA and Congress to strengthen fraud investigations, use automated detection tools and regularly update ELD requirements to ensure sustained compliance.

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

Lauding recent federal efforts to combat fake driver hours-of-service records, American Trucking Associations has released a new report outlining several recommendations to ensure the integrity of electronic logging devices and prevent fraud.

Those recommendations include requiring ELD vendors to have a verified U.S.-based presence, developing an independent certification program for devices and further strengthening enforcement. Most commercial truck drivers have been required to use ELDs to maintain their records of duty status since the federal ELD mandate took full effect in late 2019.

The ATA report on ELDs, released Nov. 16, comes on the heels of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s removal of 133 devices from its registry of approved ELDs in the largest batch ever to be stricken from the agency’s list.

Fleets cited for ELD tampering have a 56% higher crash rate, according to the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance.



Henry Hanscom, ATA’s chief advocacy and public affairs officer, praised FMCSA for its “proactive efforts to strengthen vetting procedures, enhance oversight, and identify and remove bad actors from the industry, while remaining responsive to concerns raised by legitimate industry stakeholders.”

Image
Henry Hanscom

Hanscom. (Erin Granzow Photography)

FMCSA has overhauled its procedures for vetting devices seeking placement on the agency’s registry and monitoring those already on the market.

“Those efforts have created important momentum. ATA’s recommendations provide a roadmap to continue that progress by making fraud harder to commit and easier to detect and shut down. A strong, sustainable certification system will protect responsible carriers, support law enforcement, and, most importantly, make our highways safer,” Hanscom said.

ATA’s 12-page report not only backed FMCSA’s ELD actions but also proposed additional steps for FMCSA and Congress to combat fraud.

Report recommendations

The ATA report, named “The Road to ELD Certifications,” contains six recommendations that arose from ATA’s Working Group on ELD Fraud.

The group was established by ATA’s Safety Policy Committee last year to support stronger measures to ensure ELD integrity, including third-party certification. The goal was to develop a framework targeting known types of fraud immediately while creating adaptable safeguards to counter longer-term emerging threats.

The recommendations include requiring companies registering ELDs to have a verified U.S.-based presence to help FMCSA and law enforcement officers hold providers accountable when noncompliance or fraud is identified.

“FMCSA must be able to hold entities accountable in the event of non-compliance or fraud,” the report stated in underscoring the need for companies to be located in the United States.

In addition, ATA recommends that FMCSA use automated checks to identify warning signs of fraud, such as out-of-sequence file numbers, impossible distances and driver information manipulation. It also suggests having a person review flagged records.

Other recommendations include:

  • Enhancing FMCSA’s process for investigating potential fraud

  • Building an independent certification program

  • Ensuring certification means sustained compliance

  • Regularly reviewing and updating ELD technical requirements

Image
Kevin Grove

Grove. (Karen Foote/American Trucking Associations)

“No system will eliminate every attempt at fraud, but we can make cheating significantly more difficult and costly,” said Kevin Grove, ATA’s director of safety and technology policy. “FMCSA has already demonstrated its commitment to meeting this challenge. The next step is to give the agency a stronger, lasting framework to protect the integrity of ELDs and hours-of-service compliance. ATA is committed to being a constructive partner in this ongoing effort.”

Proposals for congressional actions

The ATA report is urging Congress to dedicate additional staff and financial resources to FMCSA to accomplish its safety and enforcement goals.

The report noted that FMCSA’s limited resources may hinder its ability to effectively carry out the report's ELD fraud recommendations.

Meanwhile, congressional legislation called the GHOSTRUCK Act has been introduced by two U.S. representatives to ban people outside North America from changing a trucker’s ELD records.

In July, Republicans Dave Taylor of Ohio and Greg Steube of Florida backed the “Guarding Hours-of-Service Oversight and Stopping Tampering by Remote Unofficial Carrier Keeper Act” (H.R. 9369). It seeks to amend Title 49 of the U.S. Code to allow only authorized individuals physically located in North America to edit or annotate ELD records with driver approval.

“Foreign dispatchers should not be able to manipulate trucking safety records from halfway around the world and put American lives at risk,” Steube said. “Reports have exposed how overseas actors are falsifying driver logs, overworking truckers beyond safe limits and avoiding accountability when tragedies occur.”

 

Newsletter Signup

Subscribe to Transport Topics

Subscribe  Gift a Subscription

FOLLOW US ON GOOGLE NEWS