October 18, 2021 12:00 PM, EDT

Tesla Shares Are Roaring Back

The steering wheel of a Tesla Inc. Model 3 electric vehicle Tesla shares are up over 50% from a March 8 low of $563. (Angel Garcia/Bloomberg News)

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

Tesla Inc. shares are staging a comeback as investors expect the Elon Musk-led electric carmaker to navigate the crippling semiconductor shortage better than rivals that have been severely disrupted.

The stock gained as much as 3.8% to $875.26 on Oct. 18 in New York, before closing at $870.11, up nearly 55% from a March 8 low of $563. That came after eight weeks of gains, its longest winning streak since before the COVID-19 pandemic roiled markets. The rebound makes it the sixth-biggest publicly listed company in the U.S., firmly ahead of Berkshire Hathaway Inc.

“We believe an evolving green tidal wave will push shares of Tesla higher despite the near-term chip shortage with 3Q earnings this week another positive catalyst,” wrote Wedbush analyst Daniel Ives in a note from Oct. 17.

Chart showing Tesla's increasing stock value

Tesla shares have been steadily climbing in recent months, aided by strong quarterly results that showed the company fared much better than traditional carmakers in handling the semiconductor shortage. Deliveries for the third quarter beat all estimates.

Telsa’s handling of the chip shortage even drew praise from one of its biggest competitors.

See more transportation stock listings

“One example for the speed of Tesla: They handle the chip shortage very well — the reason: they are developing their own software,” said Herbert Diess, chairman of Volkswagen AG in a LinkedIn post. “Within just 2-3 weeks they had a new software which allows to use different chips. Impressive.”

Tesla is set to report its third-quarter earnings results on Oct. 20. It’s one of the very few global auto stocks to enjoy upward revisions in earnings estimates from analysts in the past one month, while most of the other automakers faced cuts due to the chip shortage.

The Oct. 18 surge also helped Tesla shares more than catch up with the S&P 500 Index’s gains this year. As of the Oct. 18 close, Tesla shares were up 23% year-to-date, slightly ahead of the broader index’s 19.5% advance. This had last happened in late February.

Still, some say Tesla’s trailblazing qualities in the EV race do not justify its valuation. The company is not only the biggest automaker in the world, its market capitalization of over $845 billion is much bigger than all of the top car companies put together. Critics say the company’s market capitalization also fails to reflect the wave of competing cars from legacy auto companies expected to hit the market starting next year.

Competition is indeed heating up. After being on the sidelines for years, several major legacy auto companies have announced aggressive plans to build EVs and develop the required ecosystem that includes batteries and charging station networks.

Bullish investors and analysts, on the other hand, say Tesla should not be compared to its auto peers at all. It is rather more like a technology company, and is correctly valued accordingly.

Tesla shares currently trade at 120 times their 12-month forward earnings, making them the most expensive stock on the NYSE+ FANG Index, whose other nine members include Nvidia Corp., Alphabet Inc., Apple Inc., Twitter Inc., Facebook Inc., Inc., Netflix Inc., Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. and Baidu Inc.

Despite a big push from legacy automakers across the globe to develop electric vehicles, and the emergence of several new players, Tesla has still managed to maintain its dominance in the space, producing some of the best-selling EVs globally: the Model 3 and Model Y.

“Taking a step back, with the chip shortage a major overhang on the auto space and logistical issues globally, these delivery numbers combined with this week’s likely earnings beat speaks to an EV demand trajectory that looks quite robust for Tesla heading into 4Q and 2022,” Ives wrote.

Want more news? Listen to today's daily briefing below or go here for more info: