[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]
Louisiana truckers push for reforms amid staged-crash trials
Louisiana Motor Transport Association seeks limits on damages and changes to third-party litigation funding
Staff Reporter
Amar said the industry believes Louisiana’s legal environment puts businesses in the state at a competitive disadvantage. (ianmcdonnell/Getty Images)
Key Takeaways:
- Federal prosecutors charged 63 defendants in Louisiana’s staged-crash scheme, with former attorney Danny Patrick Keating Jr. most recently receiving a 32-month prison sentence.
- Louisiana truckers say lawsuit abuse and insurance costs remain their top concerns, while a tort reform group ranked Louisiana No. 4 nationally.
- The Louisiana Motor Transport Association plans to continue seeking limits on damages, changes to third-party litigation funding and other lawsuit reforms.
Though Louisiana’s staged-crash scheme prosecutions have put the state under a national spotlight, truckers there contend lawsuit abuse and “phantom” medical damages remain top priorities for new legislation.
Federal prosecutors in New Orleans have charged 63 defendants, including plaintiffs’ attorneys, in connection with an alleged scheme to stage collisions with tractor-trailers and other vehicles in Louisiana to pursue fraudulent insurance claims and lawsuits. Two men were accused of murdering a federal witness in the staged-crash scheme. Some defendants in Operation Sideswipe have been convicted and sentenced.
Most recently, former personal injury attorney Danny Patrick Keating Jr. was sentenced Oct. 15 to 32 months in federal prison and three years of supervised release, and was ordered to pay $657,405 in restitution for conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud in staging dozens of tractor-trailer collisions. At the time of his plea in 2021, Keating admitted to representing 77 plaintiffs involved in 31 staged crashes and receiving $1.5 million in settlement claims, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
Louisiana truckers seek lawsuit reforms
Renee Amar, executive director of the Louisiana Motor Transport Association, said national attention is highlighting the industry’s long-standing concerns that trucking companies are attractive litigation targets because of their substantial insurance coverage and potential for large settlements.
“We hope these prosecutions serve as a wake-up call to lawmakers that this is not simply an insurance issue. It’s a much larger problem affecting the competitiveness of Louisiana businesses. Holding those involved accountable is an important step, but criminal prosecutions alone will not fix the broader legal environment that has allowed lawsuit abuse to flourish,” Amar said.
She said the state’s trucking industry maintains incremental legislative reforms fail to substantially lower costs for businesses to support Louisiana’s economy.

Amar
“Our priorities include eliminating ‘phantom’ medical damages, establishing limits on non-economic damages and increasing transparency or outright banning third-party litigation funding,” Amar explained.
She said lawsuit abuse and insurance costs remain the top two concerns for Louisiana truckers, even ahead of skyrocketing fuel prices.
Amar said litigation and insurance costs continue to create financial challenges for Louisiana trucking companies and make it increasingly difficult for them to operate in the state.
Founded in 1939, LMTA represents a diverse base of 300 member companies, of which 85% are small trucking companies. Members range from Louisiana’s largest trucking fleets to small, family-owned businesses operating a single truck. They haul such loads as fuel, agricultural products, construction materials and everyday consumer goods. Member businesses also include firms that support the trucking industry, including truck dealerships, equipment suppliers and other service providers.
Amar said the industry believes Louisiana’s legal environment puts businesses in the state at a competitive disadvantage.
“Our industry isn’t asking for special treatment. We’re asking for a fair legal system that protects legitimate victims while preventing abuse,” Amar said.
Louisiana ranks No. 4 among nation’s ‘Judicial Hellholes’
The American Tort Reform Foundation’s 2025-2026 Judicial Hellholes report ranks Louisiana No. 4 in the country for places where “judges systematically apply laws and court procedures” unfairly, mainly against civil lawsuit defendants. Los Angeles ranked first, followed by New York City and South Carolina.
Bob Toews, CEO of TruckDown, discusses winter readiness in the connected fleet era. Tune in above or by going to RoadSigns.ttnews.com.
“Fallout from ‘Operation Sideswipe’ continues, and a copycat fraudulent scheme was uncovered in another Louisiana parish,” the report noted. “Plaintiffs’ lawyers are well aware of Louisiana courts’ propensity for liability-expanding decisions and nuclear verdicts and spend millions of dollars on advertising.”
From Jan. 1, 2024, through June 30, 2025, plaintiffs’ attorneys in Louisiana spent $74 million on 1.37 million advertisements across television, print, radio, digital platforms and outdoor media.
According to the findings, lawsuit abuse and high tort costs cost Louisiana’s economy billions of dollars each year, including nearly 40,000 lost jobs and a per-person “tort tax” of $1,011 statewide and $2,012 in New Orleans.
“If Louisiana enacted specific reforms targeting lawsuit abuse, the state would increase its gross product by $4.6 billion,” the report predicted.
Insurance costs and claims
Insurance in Louisiana was another factor tied to the state’s high ranking as a Judicial Hellhole. National Association of Insurance Commissioners data indicated Louisiana has a rate of people filing insurance claims 200% higher than the national average.
The report also noted that the average yearly car insurance premium is $3,618, up 35% compared with the national average, despite Louisiana’s car accident statistics being slightly higher than national averages.
Mississippi has a higher traffic fatality rate than Louisiana, with 23.9 deaths per 100,000 residents compared with 19.7, yet its drivers pay nearly half as much for insurance. The report cited the number of claims filed each year as a significant contributing factor.
“Nationally, fuel prices are the trucking industry’s No. 1 concern. In Louisiana, lawsuit abuse ranks first and insurance costs rank second. That should tell lawmakers everything they need to know about the environment our trucking companies are operating in,” Amar said. “Our members have made their priorities clear, and these concerns are not going away. Until we see meaningful results that provide real relief to Louisiana trucking companies, LMTA will continue making lawsuit abuse reform and insurance affordability a priority in Baton Rouge.”
