April 28, 2021 2:15 PM, EDT

Despite Lower Bid, Canadian Pacific Touts Value of KCS Offer

A Kansas City Southern Railway locomotive passes through Kansas City, Missouri. (Whitney Curtis/Bloomberg News)A Kansas City Southern Railway locomotive passes through Kansas City, Missouri. (Whitney Curtis/Bloomberg News)

[Ensure you have all the info you need in these unprecedented times. Subscribe now.]

Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd.’s chief executive officer tried to quash speculation that a bidding war is at hand for Kansas City Southern.

Rival bidder Canadian National Railway Co. has deeper pockets, giving it an advantage if money is the sole consideration for the U.S. carrier, Canadian Pacific CEO Keith Creel said April 28.

“We don’t want a bidding war,” he said at conference sponsored by the North East Association of Rail Shippers. “It’s not something that we’ll participate in, and ultimately, it’s a war that we would not win.”

Creel’s comments were the latest in a series of negotiations in the public square over which Canadian railroad should win the U.S. carrier. Kansas City Southern is prized for its network to the southern coast of the U.S. and into Mexico.

RELATED: Merger Battle for Kansas City Southern Heats Up

Kansas City Southern erased gains after Creel spoke, trading down 1.3% to $295.65 in early afternoon trading in New York. The stock had advanced 47% this year through April 27 after a private-equity offer put the railroad in play last year. Canadian Pacific and Canadian National were little changed in Toronto.

Canadian Pacific last month reached an agreement to acquire Kansas City Southern for $28 billion. Its larger rival countered with a $33 billion bid April 20, which the U.S. railroad is considering. The offers including paying off $3 million of KCS’ debt.

Canadian Pacific is betting that its bid will gain favor with Kansas City Southern shareholders because the offer is more likely to get approved by U.S. regulators, Creel said. Canadian National’s network overlaps with Kansas City Southern’s.


Even at Level 4 autonomy, self-driving trucks will have technical limitations. In this episode, we ask how technology developers are clearing those hurdles to make autonomous trucking a reality. We bring in Boris Sofman, head of engineering for the autonomous trucking program at Waymo. Hear a snippet above, and get the full program by going to

The U.S. Surface Transportation Board, which has the final say on rail mergers in the country, also has decided that Canadian Pacific’s merger proposal is exempt from strict merger rules adopted in 2001 to slow industry consolidation. The board hasn’t ruled on Canadian National’s offer.

“There’s uncertainty in their path to a transaction. There’s certainty in our path to a transaction,” Creel said. “So, at a value standpoint, they are not the same deals.”

Regulators are also considering both suitors’ plans to use a voting trust to close a deal, which would allow shareholders to reap the benefits before the companies are merged operationally.

“If the uncertainty is cleared up, and if we both have an ability to close into trust, then what you have is a bidding war,” Creel said. “They do have a bigger balance sheet. They do have an ability to use the power of their balance sheet to buy up and snuff out competition.”

Want more news? Listen to today's daily briefing below or go here for more info: